Mattress Topper vs Mattress Pad: Which Do You Actually Need?
Quick Answer: Topper or Pad?
A mattress topper (2-4 inches thick) changes how your mattress feels, adding comfort, pressure relief, or firmness. A mattress pad (under 1 inch) protects your mattress from spills and stains without significantly changing the feel. Need more comfort? Get a topper. Need protection? Get a pad. Many people benefit from using both, with the topper underneath and a thin pad on top for protection.
4 min read
They Solve Different Problems
The confusion between mattress toppers and mattress pads is understandable since they both sit on top of your mattress. But they serve completely different purposes, and using the wrong one means the problem you are trying to solve stays unsolved.
In our experience at the store, about half the customers asking for a "mattress pad" actually need a topper. Once we explain the difference, the right choice becomes obvious.
Mattress Toppers: Changing the Feel
A mattress topper is a thick (2-4 inch) layer that sits on top of your mattress and fundamentally changes how it feels. Common materials include:
- Memory foam toppers: Add pressure relief and contouring. Best for making a firm mattress softer
- Latex toppers: Add responsive cushioning with more bounce than memory foam. Naturally cooling
-
Down/featherbed toppers: Add plush softness without changing support. Luxurious fee
l - Firm foam toppers: Add support to a mattress that is too soft. Less common but useful
A quality topper can extend the life of an aging mattress by 2-3 years, or customize a new mattress that is not quite right.
Mattress Pads: Protecting the Investment
A mattress pad is a thin (typically under 1 inch) layer designed primarily for protection. Types include:
- Waterproof pads: Block liquid from reaching your mattress. Essential for kids beds and protecting against spills
- Quilted pads: Add a thin layer of cushioning while protecting against normal wear
- Cooling pads: Thin layers with cooling technology that regulate surface temperature
- Fitted sheet-style pads: The easiest to install and wash, wrapping around the mattress like a fitted sheet
Quick Comparison
Thickness: Topper 2-4 inches, Pad under 1 inch
Purpose: Topper (changes feel), Pad (protects mattress)
Price range: Topper $100-400, Pad $30-100
Changes comfort: Topper (significantly), Pad (minimally)
Washable: Topper (usually spot clean only), Pad (machine washable)
Lifespan: Topper 3-5 years, Pad 2-3 years
Weight: Topper 10-25 lbs, Pad 2-5 lbs
When a Topper Is Not Enough
A topper can fix a mattress that is too firm, lacks pressure relief, or has minor surface wear. But if your mattress has visible sagging of more than 1.5 inches, no topper will fix the underlying support problem. The topper will simply follow the sag contour, and you will still wake up sore. In that case, it is time for a new mattress, not a topper.
Which One Do You Need?
Get a topper if: Your mattress is too firm, you want more pressure relief, you are experiencing new aches and pains, your mattress is 5+ years old and losing comfort, or you want to try a different feel without replacing the whole mattress.
Get a pad if: You want to protect a new mattress, you have kids or pets, you want waterproof protection, you are happy with your mattress comfort but want to keep it clean, or your mattress warranty requires a protector.
Get both if: You want to customize comfort AND protect
your investment. Layer the topper on the mattress first, then add a thin pad on top for protection.
Toppers and Pads in Brantford
At Mattress Miracle, we carry a selection of memory foam toppers, latex toppers, and quality mattress pads. If you are not sure which you need, bring your sleep concerns to us and we will help you figure it out. Sometimes a $150 topper solves the problem that a customer thought required a $1500 mattress. We have been giving honest advice like that since 1987.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a topper make a cheap mattress good?
A topper can make a cheap mattress more comfortable on the surface, but it cannot fix poor support. If the base mattress has good support but lacks comfort, a topper is a great solution. If the base mattress sags, a topper just puts a bandage on the problem.
Do I need a mattress pad if I have a mattress protector?
A mattress protector (thin, waterproof shell) and a mattress pad (quilted, adds minimal cushioning) serve similar protective purposes. You generally need one or the other, not both. If comfort is not a concern, a protector is sufficient.
How thick should a mattress topper be?
For noticeable comfort change: 3-4 inches. For moderate improvement: 2 inches. Under 2 inches will not significantly change how a mattress feels. Side sleepers with pressure point issues benefit most from 3-4 inch toppers.
Will a topper make my bed too tall?
A 3-inch topper adds about 3 inches to your total bed height. If you already have a 14-inch mattress on a high frame, this could make getting in and out of bed harder. Consider this especially for seniors or anyone with mobility concerns.
How do I keep a topper from sliding?
Use a fitted sheet that goes over both the topper and the mattress. Some toppers come with elastic straps or non-slip bottoms. A snug-fitting deep pocket fitted sheet is usually the easiest solution.
Visit Mattress Miracle
Find us at 441 1/2 West Street, Brantford, Ontario. Rated 4.9 stars on Google. Family-owned since 1987.
Find Your Perfect Mattress at Mattress Miracle
We are a family-owned mattress store in Brantford, helping our community sleep better since 1987. Come try mattresses in person and get honest, no-pressure advice.
441 1/2 West Street, Brantford, Ontario
Call 519-770-0001