Best Mattress Brand Canada: Restonic vs Serta vs Sealy vs Beautyrest

10 min read

How to Choose the Best Mattress Brand for You

Are you overwhelmed by all the mattress brands competing for your attention? With so many options claiming to be the best, how do you actually decide which mattress brand is right for your needs?

At Mattress Miracle in Brantford, we have helped thousands of customers navigate this exact question over our 37+ years in business. The truth is that there is no single "best" mattress brand for everyone. The right choice depends on your sleep position, body type, temperature preferences, budget, and how long you want your mattress to last.

Restonic: The Coil Count and Value Leader

Restonic is a family-owned mattress manufacturer that has been producing quality sleep products since 1938. The brand recently won the American Choice Awards National Best Brand Award, recognizing their commitment to engineering excellence.

What Sets Restonic Apart

Superior Coil Counts: Restonic consistently delivers higher coil counts than competitors at every price point. The ComfortCare Dalton and Albany features 1,222 pocket coils in queen size. For comparison, most competitors offer 800-1,000 coils in similar price ranges. More coils mean finer, more precise support that better conforms to your body.

Flippable Designs: While most mattress brands have moved to one-sided mattresses, Restonic still offers true dual-sided flippable models. The Reflections ET gives you Firm on one side and Plush on the other, while the Silk & Wool offers premium natural materials on both sides. Flippable mattresses last 10-15 years vs 7-10 for one-sided designs.

Canadian Manufacturing: Every Restonic mattress at Mattress Miracle is made in Canada. This supports domestic manufacturing jobs and means shorter shipping distances.

Natural Materials: Restonic's Revive line features Talalay Copper Latex, natural wool blends, and hand-tufted construction. These materials sleep cooler and last longer than synthetic alternatives.

Restonic Models at Mattress Miracle

↔ Scroll to see full table

Serta: The Memory Foam and Cooling Pioneer

Serta is one of the most recognized mattress brands in North America, famous for their "Counting Sheep" advertising campaign and their iComfort memory foam line.

Serta's Strengths

Memory Foam Innovation: Serta's iComfort line was among the first to popularize gel memory foam mattresses. Their cooling technologies including gel infusions and phase-change materials work well for hot sleepers who prefer the contouring feel of foam.

Brand Recognition: Serta is widely available at major retailers across Canada. If you want to try before you buy at a big-box store, Serta will be there.

Adjustable Base Compatibility: Serta mattresses are designed to work well with adjustable bed frames, making them a popular choice for seniors and those with mobility concerns.

Serta Considerations

Typical coil counts in Serta hybrid models range from 800-1,000, which is lower than comparable Restonic models. Their mattresses are primarily one-sided (non-flippable), meaning a typical lifespan of 7-10 years. Some customers report body impressions developing after 3-5 years, particularly with all-foam models.

Sealy Posturepedic: The Zoned Support Specialist

Sealy has been in the mattress business for over 140 years, and their Posturepedic line is one of the most recognizable names in the industry.

Sealy's Strengths

Posturepedic Technology: Sealy's zoned support systems target the centre third of the mattress where most body weight concentrates. This approach aims to maintain spinal alignment and reduce back pain.

Wide Availability: Like Serta, Sealy mattresses are available at most major mattress retailers across Canada, making them easy to find and try.

Variety: Sealy offers everything from budget-friendly Essentials to premium Hybrid and Posturepedic lines, giving shoppers options across price points.

Sealy Considerations

Sealy coil counts typically range from 800-1,000, which is noticeably lower than Restonic's 1,188-1,222. All current Sealy mattresses are one-sided designs with expected lifespans of 7-10 years. Some customers report issues with body impressions and premature sagging, particularly in lower-priced models.

Beautyrest: The Luxury Positioning

Beautyrest, owned by Simmons Bedding Company, positions itself as a premium mattress brand with luxury-focused marketing and higher price points.

Beautyrest's Strengths

BlackICE Cooling: The Beautyrest Black line features advanced cooling technology including phase-change materials and breathable construction designed to dissipate heat.

T2 Pocketed Coil Technology: Premium Beautyrest models use triple-stranded pocketed coils for enhanced durability and conforming support.

Luxury Brand Appeal: For shoppers who prioritize brand prestige and are willing to pay for it, Beautyrest Black represents a status choice.

Beautyrest Considerations

Entry-level Beautyrest Harmony models typically feature around 850 coils, significantly fewer than Restonic's entry-level 1,222. Premium Beautyrest Black models can cost $3,000-$5,000+, while Restonic's flagship St Charles and Elizabeth at $3,150 offers comparable or superior specifications. Beautyrest mattresses are primarily manufactured in the USA, not Canada.

Side-by-Side Brand Comparison

↔ Scroll to see full table

Why Canadian-Made Mattress Brands Matter

All Restonic mattresses at Mattress Miracle are manufactured in Canada. In contrast, Serta, Sealy, and Beautyrest mattresses sold in Canada may be manufactured in the United States, Mexico, or overseas depending on the model. When you buy Restonic, you know exactly where your mattress was made and that it supported Canadian workers.

Which Mattress Brand Should You Choose?

Choose Restonic If:

• You want the highest coil count for your budget (up to 1,222 coils)
• A flippable mattress that lasts 10-15 years appeals to you
• You value Canadian manufacturing
• Natural materials like Talalay Copper Latex and wool matter to you
• You and your partner need Split Comfort (different firmness on each side)
• You want hand-tufted artisan construction
• You are budget-conscious but refuse to compromise on quality

Choose Serta If:

• You love the contouring feel of memory foam
• Cooling technology is your top priority
• You want widespread brand availability at major retailers
• You are interested in adjustable base compatibility

Choose Sealy If:

• You specifically want Posturepedic zoned support
• Brand familiarity is important to you
• You want to easily try before you buy at major retailers

Choose Beautyrest If:

• You prioritize luxury branding and are willing to pay for it
• BlackICE cooling technology appeals to you
• You want the status of a premium brand name

Our Recommendation

At Mattress Miracle, we chose to carry Restonic because when you objectively compare specifications, construction quality, and value, Restonic consistently outperforms competitors. The 1,222 coils in the ComfortCare Dalton/Albany at $1,125 represents exceptional value that competitors cannot match. The flippable designs offer practical benefits that extend mattress life significantly. And the Canadian manufacturing aligns with our values of supporting local businesses.

That said, we encourage you to try multiple brands before making your decision. Your body knows what it likes. Visit our Brantford showroom to experience the Restonic difference firsthand.