Quick Answer: Restonic vs Serta
Restonic and Serta both make quality mattresses, but they approach sleep differently. Restonic specializes in pocket coil systems with higher coil counts (up to 1,222 coils in the ComfortCare Dalton/Albany, 1,188 in Revive models) and offers unique features like the flippable Reflections ET with dual-sided firmness and Marvelous Middle lumbar support. Serta focuses on hybrid and memory foam technology with their iComfort and Perfect Sleeper lines. For Brantford shoppers seeking durable, Canadian-made pocket coil mattresses with natural materials like Talalay Copper Latex, Restonic often delivers better long-term value. Serta appeals to those wanting advanced cooling memory foam technology.
8 min read
Brand Overview: Restonic vs Serta
Are you trying to decide between Restonic and Serta for your next mattress? Both brands have been helping people sleep better for decades, but they take different approaches to mattress design. Let us break down what makes each brand unique.
About Restonic
Restonic is a family-owned mattress manufacturer that has been producing quality sleep products since 1938. The brand won the American Choice Awards National Best Brand Award, recognizing their commitment to quality. What sets Restonic apart is their commitment to pocket coil technology and their unique Marvelous Middle system, which provides enhanced lumbar support right where you need it most. Many Restonic models feature traditional two-sided flippable designs, which can extend the mattress lifespan significantly.
Restonic at Mattress Miracle
At our Brantford showroom on West Street, we carry several Restonic models including the ComfortCare Dalton and Albany, the Revive Tiffany Rose and Jasmine, the flagship St Charles and Elizabeth, the flippable Reflections ET, and the Silk & Wool Luxury model. Dorothy, one of our sleep consultants, tells us that Restonic is often the top choice for Brantford customers who want a traditional innerspring feel with modern support technology. The flippable designs are particularly popular with customers who remember their parents' mattresses lasting 15+ years.
About Serta
Serta is one of the most recognized mattress brands in North America, famous for their "Counting Sheep" advertising campaign. The company produces a wide range of mattresses including their popular Perfect Sleeper line, the iComfort memory foam collection, and various hybrid models. Serta focuses heavily on cooling technology and pressure relief in their designs.
Mattress Construction Comparison
Coil Systems
Restonic: Specializes in pocket coil (individually wrapped coil) systems with their proprietary Marvelous Middle zoned support. Here are the actual coil counts for Restonic models at Mattress Miracle:
- ComfortCare Dalton/Albany: 1,222 coils (Queen) with zoned lumbar support
- Revive Tiffany Rose/Jasmine: 1,188 coils in a 3-zone configuration
- Revive St Charles/Elizabeth: 1,188 coils with reinforced centre zone
- Reflections ET: 1,200 posturized pocket coils
- Silk & Wool: 884 zoned pocket coils
The individually wrapped design means motion transfer is minimal, so you will not feel your partner moving during the night.
Serta: Uses a variety of coil systems depending on the model. Their hybrid mattresses typically feature pocket coils, while some models use continuous coil designs. Serta coil counts tend to be lower than Restonic in comparable price ranges, often in the 800-1000 coil range for queen sizes.
Why Coil Count Matters
Higher coil counts generally mean better contouring to your body and more precise support. With 1,200+ coils in models like the Reflections ET, Restonic mattresses can adapt more precisely to your body's curves compared to mattresses with fewer coils. Think of it like pixels on a screen: more coils equals finer detail in the support profile. The 3-zone design in Revive models also provides targeted lumbar support where you need it most.
Comfort Layers
Restonic ComfortCare Dalton/Albany: Features TempaGel gel-infused memory foam that dissipates heat instead of storing it, plus high-density foam cushioning. The Euro Top design provides a plush surface with firm underlying support.
Restonic Revive Models (Tiffany Rose, Jasmine, St Charles, Elizabeth): These premium models feature Talalay Copper Latex for responsive pressure relief, natural wool blend quilts for temperature regulation, and gel fibre layers. The copper infusion provides antimicrobial properties and enhanced heat dissipation.
Restonic Reflections ET: Triple-layer cooling system with copper-infused fabric, Joma Wool, and gel memory foam. The flippable design gives you Firm on one side, Plush on the other.
Restonic Silk & Wool: Natural silk and wool comfort layers combined with TempaGel cooling technology. This is the most natural option in the Restonic lineup.
Serta: Heavily invested in memory foam technology, especially in their iComfort line. Their foams often feature cooling gel infusions and phase-change materials designed to regulate temperature.
Edge Support
Restonic: Features SuperEdge Plus foam encasement in ComfortCare models and full foam encasement in Revive models, giving you a consistent sleep surface from edge to edge. You can sit comfortably on the edge of a Restonic mattress without feeling like you are sliding off.
Serta: Edge support varies by model. Higher-end Serta mattresses feature reinforced edge support, while budget models may have less robust edge reinforcement.
Restonic Lineup at Mattress Miracle
| Model | Coils (Queen) | Profile | Queen Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dalton (Firm) / Albany (Plush) | 1,222 | Euro Top | $1,125 | Budget-conscious, couples |
| Tiffany Rose (Firm) / Jasmine (Plush) | 1,188 | 13" Tight Top | $2,995 | Hot sleepers, allergies |
| Reflections ET (Flippable) | 1,200 | Euro Top | $2,395 | Can't decide on firmness |
| Silk & Wool (Flippable) | 884 | Flippable | $2,395 | Natural materials lovers |
| St Charles (Med-Firm) / Elizabeth (Plush) | 1,188 | 15" Euro Top | $3,150 | Premium comfort seekers |
↔ Scroll to see full table
All Restonic mattresses are Made in Canada and CertiPUR-US Certified. Split Comfort options are available on every model, perfect for couples with different firmness preferences.
Comfort and Support
The Marvelous Middle Difference
Restonic's patented Marvelous Middle technology, found in the ComfortCare Dalton and Albany, places additional support in the centre third of the mattress, where most of your body weight concentrates. This targeted lumbar support helps maintain proper spinal alignment and can reduce back pain. The 3-zone pocket coil systems in Revive models (Tiffany Rose, Jasmine, St Charles, Elizabeth) provide similar targeted support with reinforced lumbar zones. In our experience at Mattress Miracle, customers with lower back issues often notice the difference immediately when testing Restonic mattresses.
Firmness Options
Restonic: Offers a comprehensive range across all models:
- Dalton: Firm | Albany: Plush (ComfortCare)
- Tiffany Rose: Firm | Jasmine: Plush (Revive 13")
- St Charles: Medium-Firm | Elizabeth: Plush (Revive 15")
- Reflections ET: Firm on one side, Plush on the other (flippable)
- Silk & Wool: Plush, Firm, or Dual Comfort options
Most models fall in the medium to medium-firm range that suits the majority of sleepers. The flippable models give you two firmness options in one mattress.
Serta: Wide range of firmness options across their different lines. The Perfect Sleeper line tends toward medium comfort levels, while iComfort models range from plush to ultra-firm depending on the specific model.
Temperature Regulation
Restonic: Multiple cooling technologies depending on the model:
- TempaGel: Found in ComfortCare and Silk & Wool models, dissipates heat instead of storing it
- Talalay Copper Latex: In Revive models, copper infusion provides antimicrobial properties and heat dissipation
- Natural Wool: Found in Revive and Silk & Wool models, wicks moisture and regulates temperature
- Copper-Infused Fabric: In Reflections ET, actively pulls heat away from the body
The pocket coil design in all Restonic models allows for excellent airflow through the mattress.
Serta: Makes temperature regulation a major focus, especially in the iComfort line. Multiple cooling technologies including gel memory foam, phase-change covers, and breathable fire barriers work together to dissipate heat.
Durability and Lifespan
Expected Lifespan
Restonic Flippable Models (Reflections ET, Silk & Wool): These two-sided designs can last 10-15 years with proper care. Being able to flip and rotate the mattress helps prevent body impressions and sagging. The Reflections ET and Silk & Wool models feature true hand-tufting, which binds all layers together for extended durability.
Restonic Single-Sided Models (Dalton, Albany, Tiffany Rose, Jasmine, St Charles, Elizabeth): These typically last 8-12 years. While they cannot be flipped, regular rotation helps extend their life.
Serta: Most Serta mattresses have a 7-10 year expected lifespan. Like most one-sided mattresses, they cannot be flipped, only rotated. Some customers report body impressions developing after 3-5 years, particularly with memory foam models.
Extending Your Mattress Life
Regardless of brand, you can extend your mattress lifespan by: (1) Using a quality mattress protector from day one, (2) Rotating the mattress head-to-foot every 3-6 months, (3) Ensuring proper support with a solid foundation or platform bed, (4) Keeping the mattress clean and dry. With flippable Restonic models like the Reflections ET and Silk & Wool, flip and rotate for maximum longevity.
Build Quality
In our 37+ years of selling mattresses in Brantford, we have observed that Restonic tends to use denser, more durable foams in their comfort layers compared to similarly priced competitors. The hand-tufted construction in Revive models (Tiffany Rose, Jasmine, St Charles, Elizabeth, Reflections ET) binds all layers together with ribbons, preventing shifting and extending the mattress life. This means the mattress maintains its comfort longer before developing body impressions.
Price Comparison
| Category | Restonic | Serta |
|---|---|---|
| Entry Level (Twin) | $875 (Dalton/Albany) | $499-$699 |
| Mid-Range (Queen) | $1,125-$2,395 | $999-$1,499 |
| Premium (Queen) | $2,995-$3,150 | $1,699-$2,599 |
↔ Scroll to see full table
Prices are in Canadian dollars based on typical retail pricing in the Brantford market. The ComfortCare Dalton/Albany at $1,125 (Queen) offers exceptional value with 1,222 coils and TempaGel cooling. The Reflections ET at $2,395 (Queen) provides premium features including 1,200 coils, triple-layer cooling, and flippable dual comfort at a competitive price point.
Warranty and Service
Restonic: Offers 10-year limited warranties on all models. The flippable mattresses often last longer because the design allows for more even wear. Warranty coverage includes manufacturing defects and excessive sagging (typically 1.5 inches or more). All Restonic mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified, meaning they meet strict standards for emissions, content, and durability.
Serta: Typically offers 10-year warranties on most models, with some premium lines extending to 15 or 20 years. Serta has a well-established warranty service network across Canada, which can make claims processing more streamlined.
Local Warranty Support
When you buy from Mattress Miracle in Brantford, we handle warranty claims directly with the manufacturer on your behalf. Whether you choose Restonic or Serta, you have local support just a phone call away at (519) 770-0001. No need to deal with 1-800 numbers or online forms. We also offer a 60-night comfort guarantee on select Restonic models.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Restonic If:
- You want a flippable two-sided mattress for maximum durability
- Higher coil counts (1,200+) and targeted lumbar support appeal to you
- You prefer a more traditional innerspring feel with modern technology
- You value natural materials like Talalay Copper Latex and wool
- You sleep hot and want multiple cooling technologies
- You want Canadian-made products (all Restonic mattresses are manufactured in Canada)
- You and your partner have different firmness preferences (Split Comfort available)
Choose Serta If:
- You love the contouring feel of memory foam
- Cooling technology is your top priority
- You want the brand recognition and widespread availability
- You prefer the latest foam innovations over traditional coil systems
- You are interested in adjustable base compatibility
Our Recommendation
At Mattress Miracle, we believe the best mattress is the one that feels right to you. Both Restonic and Serta make quality mattresses, but they feel different when you lie on them. That is why we always encourage customers to visit our Brantford showroom and spend at least 10-15 minutes testing each mattress in their preferred sleep position.
Brad, our store manager, often tells customers: "The specs on paper matter less than how the mattress feels when you are actually lying on it. Your body knows what it likes." For many of our Brantford customers, the ComfortCare Dalton or Albany hits the sweet spot of quality, support, and value, while those wanting premium features often gravitate toward the St Charles or Elizabeth with their Talalay Copper Latex and hand-tufted construction.
Try Restonic at Mattress Miracle
Visit our family-owned showroom in Brantford to test the full Restonic lineup including the ComfortCare, Revive, and Luxury collections. Talia, Dorothy, and Brad are here to answer your questions and help you find the perfect mattress for your sleep style and budget.
441 1/2 West Street, Brantford, Ontario
Hours: Mon-Wed 10 a.m. - 6 p.m., Thu-Fri 10 a.m. - 7 p.m., Sat 10 a.m. - 5 p.m., Sun 12 p.m. - 4 p.m.
Call 519-770-0001White glove delivery available to Brantford, Hamilton, Burlington, Kitchener, Waterloo, Guelph, Cambridge, Mississauga, Toronto, and surrounding areas.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Restonic better than Serta?
Neither brand is objectively "better." Restonic excels in coil count (up to 1,222 coils), flippable designs, and natural materials like Talalay Copper Latex. Serta leads in memory foam innovation and brand recognition. The best choice depends on your personal comfort preferences. We carry Restonic at our Brantford showroom and recommend trying mattresses in person.
Are Restonic mattresses made in Canada?
Yes, all Restonic mattresses sold at Mattress Miracle are manufactured in Canada. This means shorter shipping distances, support for Canadian manufacturing jobs, and easier warranty service. Serta mattresses sold in Canada may be manufactured in Canada or the United States depending on the model.
Which Restonic mattress has the most coils?
The ComfortCare Dalton and Albany feature 1,222 pocket coils in queen size, the highest coil count in the Restonic lineup at Mattress Miracle. The Reflections ET follows closely with 1,200 coils, while Revive models (Tiffany Rose, Jasmine, St Charles, Elizabeth) have 1,188 coils.
Which mattress lasts longer, Restonic or Serta?
Restonic's flippable two-sided mattresses like the Reflections ET and Silk & Wool typically last longer, often 10-15 years with proper care. Serta mattresses generally have a 7-10 year lifespan. The ability to flip and rotate Restonic mattresses helps prevent premature sagging and body impressions.
Is the Restonic Marvelous Middle worth it?
Many customers find the Marvelous Middle technology in the ComfortCare Dalton and Albany noticeably improves lower back support. If you sleep on your back or stomach, or if you experience lower back pain, the targeted lumbar support can make a meaningful difference in your sleep quality and morning comfort. The 3-zone coils in Revive models provide similar targeted support.
Does Mattress Miracle carry Serta mattresses?
We specialize in the Restonic lineup at our Brantford showroom. For Serta and other brands, we can often special order or recommend comparable alternatives from our selection. Our goal is to find the right mattress for your needs. Visit us to test the Restonic ComfortCare, Revive, and Luxury collections.
What is Split Comfort?
Split Comfort means we can build one mattress with different firmness on each side. For example, a queen mattress can have Firm on the left side for one partner and Plush on the right side for the other. This option is available on all Restonic models at Mattress Miracle at no extra charge, making it perfect for couples with different preferences.
What is Talalay Copper Latex?
Talalay Copper Latex is a premium material used in Restonic Revive models (Tiffany Rose, Jasmine, St Charles, Elizabeth). It combines responsive, breathable latex with copper infusion for antimicrobial properties and enhanced heat dissipation. It moulds to your body for pressure relief while sleeping cooler than traditional memory foam.
Sources
- Jacobson BH, Boolani A, Smith DB. Changes in back pain, sleep quality, and perceived stress after introduction of new bedding systems. J Chiropr Med. 2009;8(1):1-8. DOI: 10.1016/j.jcm.2008.09.002
- Radwan A, Fess P, James D, et al. Effect of different mattress designs on promoting sleep quality, pain reduction, and spinal alignment in adults with or without back pain. Sleep Health. 2015;1(4):257-267. DOI: 10.1016/j.sleh.2015.08.001
- Kovacs FM, Abraira V, Peña A, et al. Effect of firmness of mattress on chronic non-specific low-back pain: randomised, double-blind, controlled, multicentre trial. Lancet. 2003;362(9396):1599-1604. DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(03)14792-7