Is Silk and Snow Too Soft? Who It Works For and What to Try Instead

Reading Time: 7 minutes

Silk & Snow is a well-regarded Canadian mattress brand owned by Sleep Country since 2022. Its foam and hybrid models have earned solid reviews from side sleepers and lighter-weight buyers. But a consistent complaint surfaces across review sites, Reddit threads, and customer feedback: for some people, it is simply too soft.

That is not a knock on the product. Softness is not a flaw if the mattress was designed for that comfort level. But if you are a heavier person, a stomach sleeper, or someone who needs real lumbar support, "medium soft" can mean back pain by month three.

Silk & Snow Firmness Ratings by Model

Silk & Snow sells three mattress models in Canada. Each has a different firmness profile, and understanding where they sit on the 1-to-10 scale (1 = extra soft, 10 = extra firm) is the starting point for this conversation.

Silk & Snow does not offer a firm version of their foam mattress. This is a genuine gap in their lineup. If you need a 7 or higher on the firmness scale, you will not find it here. The Hybrid is the firmest of the three, but its pocketed coil system still sits squarely in medium territory.

8 min read

Who Finds Silk & Snow Too Soft

Softness is relative. What feels "just right" to a 130 lb side sleeper will feel like a hammock to a 250 lb back sleeper. Here is a breakdown of who consistently reports the Silk & Snow as too soft:

Back sleepers over 200 lbs. This is the most common group that reports issues. The foam compresses enough under heavier body weight that the lumbar region loses the resistance it needs. Sleep Foundation testers noted that "back sleepers over 230 pounds tend to find both models to be too soft for optimal support." The hybrid provides slightly more resistance through its coil layer, but it still sits in medium territory.

Stomach sleepers. Stomach sleeping requires the firmest mattresses of any sleep position. Without adequate surface resistance, the hips sink below shoulder level, creating a pronounced lumbar arch. Research published in Applied Sciences (2024) found that firmness mismatches were most acute for stomach sleepers, who experienced measurably lower spinal alignment scores on medium and soft mattresses compared to firm surfaces (Sljivic et al., 2024).

Combination sleepers who roll to their back during the night. If you start on your side but shift to your back while sleeping, the foam may provide enough pressure relief in side position but too little support when you roll. Many combination sleepers report waking with lower back stiffness from this firmness mismatch, even if the mattress feels fine initially.

What Sleep Science Says About Mattress Softness

The broader research on mattress firmness and sleep quality consistently points in the same direction: medium-firm outperforms soft for spinal alignment across most adult populations.

A 2015 systematic review in Sleep Health analysed data across multiple randomised controlled trials and found that medium-firm mattresses were more consistently associated with improved sleep quality and reduced back pain than either soft or firm options. The key finding relevant here: soft mattresses were associated with increased spinal flexion during sleep, particularly in back and stomach positions (Radwan et al., 2015).

None of this makes Silk & Snow a bad mattress. It makes it a mattress designed for a specific comfort preference. The problem arises when buyers purchase based on brand recognition or price rather than personal fit, discover the softness mismatch at week three, and either adapt (at the cost of sleep quality) or begin a return process.

What Customers Actually Report

Across Reddit's r/Mattress community and third-party review sites, several consistent patterns emerge from Silk & Snow owners who found it too soft:

• Sinking sensation by month two: Many owners report the mattress feels appropriately firm when new, then progressively softer as the foam breaks in. This is normal for open-cell memory foam, but it means a mattress already at the softer end of medium can shift into genuinely soft territory after regular use.
• Hip and rib discomfort for side sleepers over 180 lbs: Heavier side sleepers note that while the mattress contours well, the lack of pushback causes the shoulder and hip to sink past optimal pressure-relief into uncomfortable compression.
• Morning lower back stiffness: Particularly reported by back sleepers. The lumbar region loses resistance as the night progresses and body heat softens the foam further.

Firmer Alternatives Worth Considering

If Silk & Snow is too soft for your needs, here are the alternatives worth knowing about at different price points in the Canadian market.

Within the Silk & Snow lineup: The Hybrid ($950 Queen) is the firmest option they offer. If you have the foam and find it too soft, trading up to the Hybrid will add some coil resistance. But if you need a true firm mattress (7+ on the scale), Silk & Snow does not have that option.

Restonic ComfortCare at Mattress Miracle ($1,125 Queen): This is a medium-firm pocketed coil mattress with 1,222 individually wrapped coils. The coil system provides a consistent support layer that does not compress progressively the way foam does. In our showroom, this is the mattress we most often recommend to customers coming from failed online purchases. The coil count is higher than most online hybrids at the same price point, and you can test the actual feel in-store before committing.

Restonic Revive Reflections ($2,395 Queen): A dual-sided flippable mattress with one firm side and one medium side. If your firmness needs change or you share a bed with a partner who prefers a softer feel, the flippable design gives you options without buying two mattresses.

Douglas Summit ($1,299 Queen): An online option from GoodMorning.com rated at 6.5 to 7 on the firmness scale, which is noticeably firmer than the Silk & Snow foam. If your issue is specifically the online shopping preference, this is worth considering.

Try the Right Firmness Before You Buy in Brantford

Brad often says the same thing to customers who come in after a failed online mattress purchase: "The 100-night trial is a return policy, not a selection process." The whole point of a home trial is to compensate for not being able to test the mattress before buying. It is not designed to replace that experience.

At Mattress Miracle, we carry multiple firmness levels across the Restonic lines. You can lie on a medium, a medium-firm, and a firm mattress on the same visit, in your actual sleep position, for as long as you need. Talia in our showroom will walk you through what the difference feels like for your body weight and sleep style, not what a website says it feels like.

We have been doing this in Brantford since 1987. That is 38 years of helping people find the right firmness the first time.

Sources

1. Caggiari, G., et al. (2021). What type of mattress should be chosen to avoid back pain and improve sleep quality? Review of the literature. Journal of Orthopaedic and Traumatology, 22(1), 51. PMC8655046.
2. Radwan, A., et al. (2015). Effect of different mattress designs on promoting sleep quality, pain reduction, and spinal alignment in adults with or without back pain; systematic review of controlled trials. Sleep Health, 1(4), 257-267.
3. Sljivic, M., et al. (2024). Investigating the Impact of Long-Term Use on Mattress Firmness and Sleep Quality. Applied Sciences, 14(21), 10016.
4. PMC12071755. (2024). The Effect of Mattress Firmness on Sleep Architecture and PSG Characteristics. National Library of Medicine.
5. Sleep Foundation. (2026). Silk & Snow Hybrid Mattress Review. sleepfoundation.org