Mattress Scams to Avoid: Fake Reviews, Bait-and-Switch, and Hidden Fees

Reading Time: 11 minutes

Fake Reviews and Affiliate Review Sites

Most people start mattress shopping the same way they start shopping for anything: they search for reviews. And that is exactly where the first scam begins.

The mattress industry has one of the most compromised review ecosystems of any consumer product category. Many of the websites that appear at the top of Google for "best mattress" or "mattress reviews" earn their revenue through affiliate commissions. They get paid a percentage of every sale they refer. That creates an obvious problem: the site's income depends on which brands they recommend.

The Casper and Sleepopolis case

In April 2016, mattress company Casper sued three mattress review blogs, including Sleepopolis, alleging they failed to disclose affiliate commissions from Casper's competitors. The Sleepopolis owner had received $40,000 in SEO consulting fees from Casper competitor Leesa while giving Leesa favourable reviews.

Here is where it gets interesting. After the lawsuits settled, Casper financed a media company's acquisition of Sleepopolis itself. The site then published a revised, positive Casper review complete with coupon codes. The "independent" review site was now effectively owned by a mattress company. NPR reported on these cozy ties in October 2017.

GhostBed's fake review site

In February 2017, mattress company Purple filed a lawsuit against "Honest Mattress Reviews," a website that had published a study claiming Purple's polyethylene powder was a health hazard. The court found that GhostBed, a Purple competitor, had concealed its financial and operational ties to the site. GhostBed was running a fake "independent" review site to defame a competitor. The site was shut down.

In Canada, the Competition Bureau issued a warning in January 2024 that businesses are liable when employees post reviews without disclosing their connection to the company, even if the reviews are their honest opinion. Starting June 2025, private citizens can seek leave from the Competition Tribunal to bring their own proceedings against deceptive marketing.

How to spot a compromised review site

• Coupon codes and discount links: If a review site offers a promo code for the brand it rates highest, that site earns a commission when you click through. The review is an advertisement.
• No mention of downsides: Every mattress has trade-offs. A review that is entirely positive is not a review.
• Reviewer profiles with multiple high-ticket reviews in quick succession: Real people do not buy and review four mattresses in two months.
• "Best mattress" lists that rotate based on commissions: If a site's top pick changes every few months to whichever brand is paying the most, the rankings are for sale.

Bait-and-Switch and Model Name Games

This is one of the oldest tricks in mattress retail, and it is still going strong.

The exclusive model name scam

Mattress manufacturers create exclusive names and model numbers for each retailer. The same mattress might be called "the Royal Comfort 3000" at one store and "the Supreme Rest Elite" at another. The construction, materials, and factory are identical. Only the name on the label is different.

The purpose is simple: you cannot comparison shop. When you ask one store to price-match, they will say "we don't carry that model." And technically, they are right. The name is different even though the mattress is the same. Some retailers actively request this arrangement from manufacturers to protect their margins.

The doorbuster that is always sold out

A store advertises an incredible deal on a specific mattress. You arrive to find it is "sold out" or positioned in the least favourable spot on the floor. The salesperson steers you to a more expensive option that they had planned to sell you all along.

This is textbook bait-and-switch, and it is illegal in Canada. Section 74.04 of the Competition Act prohibits advertising a product at a bargain price when it is not available in reasonable quantities. Penalties for corporations can reach $10 million on a first offence, or three times the benefit obtained from the deception.

Hidden Return Fees and Fine Print

The online mattress industry built itself on "risk-free trials." Buy a mattress, sleep on it for 100 nights, and return it if you do not love it. That sounds generous. The details are often less so.

Restocking and return fees

Some retailers charge restocking fees of $99 to $200 when you return a mattress. Others charge a separate "return delivery" fee. At one major chain, returning a mattress involves a $99.99 restocking fee plus a $99.99 return delivery fee. If you received a "free" adjustable base with your purchase, returning the mattress can result in a $499 charge for that base.

To be fair, some companies do offer genuinely free returns with no restocking fees. The key is reading the full return policy before you buy, not after.

The donation requirement

Many online brands require you to donate the mattress to a charity as a condition of the return. That sounds simple until you discover that many charities in your area do not accept used mattresses due to bed bug policies. If you cannot find an approved charity to take it, you cannot complete the return. Some brands require a donation receipt and photograph as proof before processing your refund.

Warranty traps

This one catches a lot of people. Most mattress warranties contain a clause that any stain, including sweat marks or water stains, voids the entire warranty. Inspectors may use black lights to detect stains invisible to the naked eye. Even if the defect is clearly structural, like a 2-inch sag in the centre, a stain gives the manufacturer grounds to deny your claim.

Other warranty-voiding traps to watch for:

• Improper support: Using the wrong bed frame or a foundation with too few slats can void your warranty, even if the defect has nothing to do with the support.
• Not following rotation instructions: Some manufacturers require periodic head-to-foot rotation. If you do not follow the schedule, they may deny your claim.
• Removing the law tag: While consumers are legally allowed to remove the mattress tag, it serves as proof of purchase and materials for warranty claims. Keep it on.

"Comfort guarantee" fine print

Read these carefully. Many comfort guarantees are exchange-only with no refund option, and the exchange must be for a mattress of equal or greater value. Some require that you purchased specific accessories (like a premium pillow and mattress protector) at the time of the original sale to qualify. Others deduct a percentage of the original price for each month you have had the mattress.

The Perpetual Sale Illusion

If you have ever noticed that mattress stores seem to always be having a sale, you are not imagining things. Many retailers inflate their "regular" prices so they can permanently advertise discounts. The "regular price" is a fiction that no customer has ever paid.

The Competition Act addresses this directly. For a retailer to claim a product is "on sale," more than 50% of sales must have occurred at the claimed regular price within a reasonable period, typically one year. If a mattress has never actually sold at the listed "regular" price, the discount claim is misleading.

This is exactly what Hudson's Bay was caught doing. And they are not the only ones. The mattress industry relies heavily on price anchoring: show a high price, cross it out, and display a lower "sale" price that is actually the normal price. The psychology is well documented. A $2,000 mattress "on sale for $999" feels like a steal. A $999 mattress at full price feels expensive. They are the same mattress at the same price.

The "going out of business" sale that never ends

This tactic is less common in Canada thanks to Competition Bureau enforcement, but it still appears. A store announces a closing sale with "everything must go" pricing, creates urgency, and then never actually closes. In some cases, a store closes briefly and reopens under a slightly different name, running the same "grand opening" sale indefinitely.

Material Buzzwords That Mean Nothing

The mattress industry loves inventing terminology. Here are terms that sound impressive but are not regulated or standardised:

• "Orthopaedic" has no regulated meaning in the mattress industry. Any manufacturer can label any mattress orthopaedic.
• "Medical-grade" is not a standard. There is no certification body that grades mattress foam for medical use.
• "Space-age foam," "nano-coil technology," "quantum sleep surface" are marketing labels for ordinary materials. There are only three broad categories of foam: polyurethane, memory foam, and latex. Everything else is a brand name for one of these.
• "Luxurious," "premium," "deluxe" tell you nothing about the actual construction, density, or durability of the materials inside.

The single most useful specification for mattress foam quality is density, measured in pounds per cubic foot. Higher density foam lasts longer and provides more consistent support. Most brands hide this number. If a salesperson cannot tell you the foam density, that is a red flag.

Pressure Sales Tactics

A mattress is something you use for 8 to 10 years. No legitimate purchase decision for something that important needs to happen in 20 minutes.

Red flags to watch for

• "This price is only available today" is almost never true. If a store offers you a price today, they will offer the same price tomorrow. This is artificial urgency designed to prevent you from comparison shopping.
• "I need to check with my manager" is a negotiation tactic, not a genuine authority issue. The salesperson already knows the lowest price they can offer.
• "Another customer was looking at this one earlier" creates scarcity pressure. Even if true, it is irrelevant to whether the mattress is right for you.
• Commission-based salespeople have a financial incentive to steer you toward higher-priced options. Ask whether the sales team works on commission. At Mattress Miracle, our team does not.

A good mattress store will encourage you to take your time, lie on multiple options for at least 10 to 15 minutes each, and come back for a second visit if you want. Any store that pressures you into a same-day decision is prioritising their sale over your sleep.

How to Protect Yourself

Shopping for a mattress does not have to feel like walking through a minefield. A few simple habits will protect you from most of these tactics.

Before you shop

• Research the return policy before you buy, not after. Look for restocking fees, donation requirements, mandatory accessory purchases, and exchange-only limitations.
• Ignore "best mattress" lists from sites that offer coupon codes. They are advertisements, not reviews.
• Look for verified purchase reviews on the retailer's own site, Google Reviews, or Reddit. These are harder to fake than reviews on dedicated review sites.
• Know your rights. In Ontario, there is no general legal right to return or exchange goods. The retailer's posted return policy is the contract. Read it.

In the store

• Ask about foam density and coil count. If the salesperson cannot provide these, the store may be hiding something.
• Ask whether the sales team works on commission. Commission creates a conflict of interest between what is best for you and what is most profitable for the salesperson.
• Lie down for at least 15 minutes in your usual sleeping position. A 30-second sit on the edge tells you nothing about how a mattress will feel at 3 a.m.
• Take photos of the mattress tag (the law tag with materials and manufacturer info). This helps you research the actual construction later.
• Never buy on the first visit unless you are genuinely confident. Sleep on the decision, literally.

After you buy

• Put a mattress protector on immediately. Any stain can void your warranty.
• Keep all receipts, tags, and documentation. You will need these for warranty claims.
• Follow the manufacturer's care instructions including rotation schedules.
• Use the proper foundation or bed frame specified by the manufacturer.

Sources

1. Competition Bureau of Canada. "Hudson's Bay to pay $4.5 million to settle Competition Bureau investigation." Canada.ca, May 2019.
2. Competition Bureau of Canada. "Bait and switch selling." Canada.ca.
3. Competition Bureau of Canada. "Online reviews posted by employees: businesses could be liable." Canada.ca, January 2024.
4. Competition Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-34, ss. 74.01, 74.04. Government of Canada.
5. Federal Trade Commission. "FTC announces final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials." FTC.gov, August 2024.
6. Fast Company. "The War to Sell You a Mattress Is an Internet Nightmare." October 2016.
7. NPR. "Reporter Pulls Blanket Off Cozy Ties Between Mattress Companies and Reviewers." October 2017.
8. CBC News. "Competition Bureau investigates HBC, Sears for deceptive mattress marketing." February 2017.

Related Reading

• Mattress Types: The Complete Guide to Finding Your Best Fit
• Best Time to Buy a Mattress in Canada: When Sales Are Real
• How Long Does a Mattress Last? Signs It Is Time to Replace Yours
• Mattress Firmness Scale Explained: Finding Your Ideal Comfort Level
• Mattress Miracle Reviews: Why Brantford Trusts Us for Sleep
• The Hidden Costs of 'Free' Mattress Trials