How to Dispose Pillows: 5 Practical Ways to Get Rid of Old Pillows

Old pillows accumulate in linen closets, basements, and donation bags for longer than they should because it is not immediately obvious what the right move is. The garbage feels wasteful. The thrift store turns them away. The blue box is the wrong answer. This guide cuts through the confusion with five concrete ways to get rid of old pillows, covering community programs in Ontario, hands-on repurposing projects, and the correct route when nothing else applies.

Quick Reference: 5 Ways to Dispose of Old Pillows

1. Drop off at a textile recycling bin
2. Donate to an animal shelter or community organisation
3. Repurpose as a pet bed, draft stopper, or floor cushion
4. Compost natural fills in your backyard compost
5. Bag and place in general household waste as a last resort

Each of these routes works differently depending on the pillow's condition and fill type. Here is how to use each one.

Way 1: Drop Off at a Textile Recycling Bin

Textile recycling bins are the most broadly available option for pillow disposal in Ontario and do not require the pillow to be in donation-quality condition. These bins are operated by non-profit organisations and textile recyclers, and the materials they collect go to secondhand resale markets, industrial rag production, and fibre recycling facilities, keeping the material out of landfill.

Where to Find Textile Bins in Ontario

• Diabetes Canada (Clothesline): Blue bins at grocery and retail parking lots across Ontario. Accepts household textiles including pillows. Items must be clean, dry, and in a sealed bag. Find the nearest bin at diabetes.ca/clothesline.
• Kidney Foundation of Canada: Drop-off locations and in some areas free home pickup. Accepts clothing, footwear, and household textiles. Find locations at kidney.ca/kidney-kars.
• Planet Aid: Yellow bins at various locations across Ontario. Accepts all textiles regardless of condition, including items too worn for resale. Find bins at planetaid.org.
• Municipal Transfer Stations: Many Ontario municipalities have textile drop-off areas at their waste facilities. In Brantford, the City of Brantford Waste Management Facility at 195 Henry Street accepts household textiles. Check your local municipality's website for what is accepted.

How to Prepare Pillows for Textile Drop-Off

Remove the pillowcase. Place the pillow in a clean, sealed plastic bag. Make sure the pillow is dry. Wet or damp pillows create mould problems inside the bins and may be rejected at the recycling facility. Drop off during daylight hours when the bin is clearly accessible.

Way 2: Donate to an Animal Shelter or Community Organisation

While mainstream thrift stores (Goodwill, Value Village, most Salvation Army locations) do not accept used pillows, several types of organisations in Ontario do. A lightly used pillow with no mould, no persistent smell, and intact ticking is worth offering before sending it to recycling.

Animal Shelters and Humane Societies

This is the most reliable donation route for used pillows in most Ontario communities. Local SPCA offices and humane societies use old pillows and blankets as bedding in animal kennels and recovery areas. The condition requirement is more relaxed than for human use, so a pillow that is too flat or worn for sleep is often perfectly adequate as animal bedding.

Call before you drop off. Ask how many pillows they can currently accept, since storage space is finite. Most shelters in the Brantford, Hamilton, and Guelph areas accept linen donations at the front desk during regular operating hours.

Homeless Shelters and Drop-In Centres

During winter months, many Ontario shelters operate at or near capacity and have urgent need for basic bedding. Clean pillows in reasonable condition are sometimes accepted by emergency shelters and overnight drop-in centres. Call ahead to confirm, as policies change based on current inventory and health regulations.

Community Sharing Platforms

Buy-nothing Facebook groups, local mutual aid networks, and free sections of Kijiji and Facebook Marketplace are effective for offering usable pillows to community members who want them. No condition standards, no middleman, and the pillows stay in use locally.

Way 3: Repurpose at Home , DIY Projects

Repurposing is the simplest option when the pillow still has any structural integrity, even if it is no longer suitable for sleep. These projects require minimal effort and create something genuinely useful.

Pet Bed

A used pillow inside a durable fabric cover makes a good dog or cat bed. Use a canvas tote bag with the handles tied shut, sew a simple cover from an old pillowcase, or buy an inexpensive pet bed cover at a dollar store and stuff it with the old pillow. Replace the cover when it gets dirty while reusing the pillow fill inside.

Draft Stopper

Draft stoppers reduce cold air infiltration at the base of exterior doors, which is a meaningful energy saving in Ontario winters. A standard bed pillow can be placed at the base of a door without modification. For a neater result, fold the pillow lengthwise and slide it into a fabric tube sewn shut at both ends. A bolster-style pillow needs no modification at all, as its shape fits door gaps naturally.

Floor Cushion

Stack two or three worn flat pillows inside a large pillowcase or inside a custom cover sewn from durable canvas or denim. Sew or tie shut. The combined thickness creates a serviceable floor cushion for reading nooks, meditation, children's play areas, or guest sleeping situations.

Packing and Moving Padding

Old pillows are excellent protective padding for fragile items during a move or when shipping breakable objects. Wrap mirrors, framed pictures, glass lamp bases, and ceramics in old pillows secured with packing tape. The fill absorbs impact, and the outer ticking prevents scratching on finished surfaces.

Garden Knee Pad

Place a flat old pillow inside a sturdy resealable plastic bag or a waterproof fabric cover. Use it as a knee pad during gardening. It lifts your knees off hard soil and protects joints during planting, weeding, and low-level work. Rinse the cover when dirty and replace the pillow when the fill deteriorates too far for even this basic application.

Stuffing for Crafts and New Cushions

Polyester fibrefill from old pillows is exactly the same material sold in bags as craft stuffing for soft toys, throw pillows, and seat cushions. Cut open the ticking along a seam, remove the fill, loosen any clumps, and use it in any project that calls for polyester stuffing. One bed pillow typically yields enough fill for two to three small throw pillows or a medium floor cushion.

Way 4: Compost Natural Fills

If your old pillow has a natural fill, composting is a genuinely circular solution that returns organic material to the soil rather than sending it to landfill or recycling. You need to separate the fill from the outer ticking first, as most ticking is synthetic even on pillows marketed as natural.

Compostable fills include buckwheat hulls, cotton batting (100% natural only), wool, and down and feathers. Non-compostable fills include polyester fibrefill, memory foam, and latex. For a full fill-by-fill breakdown, see our article on how to dispose of old pillows, which covers composting in detail.

To compost pillow fill at home, open the ticking along one seam, remove the fill, and add it to your backyard compost bin in small amounts mixed with green matter such as kitchen scraps or grass clippings. Down and feather fills in particular take a long time to break down but are a good nitrogen source. If you have a large amount, work it into garden beds directly as a slow-release soil amendment.

Way 5: General Household Waste (Last Resort)

If the pillow is too degraded for any of the above options and no textile recycling bin is nearby, general waste is the last resort. Before placing it in the garbage, extract any natural fill that can be composted and set it aside. If the outer ticking is 100% natural cotton or linen, it can also go to compost. This reduces the synthetic material going to landfill even when complete diversion is not possible.

Do not put pillows in the blue-box recycling bin. They do not belong there and will contaminate the recyclable load. Ontario's blue-box program does not accept textiles of any kind.

Check your municipal waste schedule before putting pillows at the kerb. Some Ontario municipalities have large-item collection days or specific textile pickup programs that operate separately from regular garbage collection. Placing a pillow in a regular garbage bag ensures it gets collected in most municipalities, but a separately bagged large item may be easier for collectors in some areas.

Community Programs in Ontario Worth Knowing

Beyond the major national organisations already mentioned, several Ontario-specific programs are useful to know for pillow and textile disposal:

• Re-Use It Centre (Hamilton): Accepts a range of household items for redistribution, including bedding in some cases. Contact the centre directly for current accepted items.
• Recycle My Electronics (Ontario): While this program focuses on electronics, many municipal transfer stations that host electronics collection also have textile collection areas on site, making one trip serve multiple disposal needs.
• Community Resource Centres: Many Ontario communities have resource centres or second-hand shops operated by local non-profit organisations that accept items thrift stores reject, including used bedding. Search your city name along with "community resource centre" or "give and take" to find local options.
• School and scout drives: Local schools and scouting groups occasionally run textile and household item collection drives as fundraisers or community projects. These are informal and intermittent but worth watching for in local community boards.

Connecting Disposal to Your Next Purchase

The best time to deal with an old pillow's disposal is when you are replacing it, not after the new one has already arrived. Planning the disposal in advance, whether that means checking local textile bin locations, calling the animal shelter, or deciding on a repurposing project, makes it far more likely the old pillow avoids the garbage.

When you do replace your pillow, choosing a quality pillow protector from the start extends the life of the new one significantly. A waterproof or dust-mite-proof barrier between the pillow and the pillowcase prevents the sweat and oil saturation that degrades fills and creates the stain and odour problems that make a pillow hard to donate when its time comes. See our guide on how often pillows should be replaced for replacement timing by fill type, and our overview of pillows and blankets for product options available in Canada.

References

1. Diabetes Canada. Clothesline Donation Program , Find a Bin. diabetes.ca
2. Kidney Foundation of Canada. Kidney Kars Program. kidney.ca
3. Planet Aid. Drop-Off Bin Locations. planetaid.org
4. City of Brantford. Waste Management Facility Information. brantford.ca
5. Ontario SPCA. Shelter Donation Guidelines. ontariospca.ca
6. Zero Waste Canada. Practical Guides to Textile Waste Reduction. zerowastecanada.ca

8 min read

Visit Our Brantford Showroom

We are located at 441½ West Street in downtown Brantford. Free parking available. Our team does not work on commission, so you get honest advice based on your needs.

Mattress Miracle , 441½ West Street, Brantford, ON , (519) 770-0001

Hours: Monday–Wednesday 10am–6pm, Thursday–Friday 10am–7pm, Saturday 10am–5pm, Sunday 12pm–4pm.

Once you have sorted your old pillows, come see us for quality replacements. We carry pillows for every sleep position and budget, and we are happy to help you find something that works for how you sleep.