Is The Scott Living Mattress Worth It? Read Our Review

9 min read • Last updated: February 25, 2026

Scott Living Mattress Review: What Buyers Should Know

Scott Living mattresses are a collaboration between HGTV's Property Brothers (Drew and Jonathan Scott) and Restonic, a mattress manufacturer dating back to 1938. The celebrity branding is slick, but what about the actual mattress? Here's what we've learned from customer experiences and our own observations.

What Scott Living Offers

The Scott Living line includes several construction types: microcoil, hybrid, memory foam, and latex designs. The hybrid model, which is the most popular, features Alumilast memory foam, Talalay latex, Quantum edge support, and Restonic's Q5 coil system.

These mattresses are handcrafted in the United States and come with a 10-year warranty for manufacturing defects. Price-wise, you're looking at around $900 USD for a queen memory foam option, $1,200 for the hybrid, and about $2,000 for the latex version.

What People Like

The positive reviews highlight several strengths:

• Initial comfort: Many buyers report excellent comfort out of the box
• Cool sleep: The hybrid construction with latex seems to regulate temperature well
• Pressure relief: People with hip and back pain often report improvement
• Motion isolation: Couples appreciate that movement doesn't transfer across the mattress
• Support: The coil system provides good underlying support

One reviewer noted they "haven't had such a good night's sleep in so long" and no longer wake up with back and hip pain. Another said the mattress helped their back tremendously after previously waking with back pain every morning.

The Durability Question

Here's where reviews get complicated. Several customers report problems that emerge after the first year or two:

• Body impressions developing where sleepers lie
• Foam layers deteriorating and losing support
• The mattress feeling dramatically different than when purchased

One customer who "loved this bed the first 2 years" reported that "after a few years, the foam top deteriorated, left body imprints, and no longer supported us." Another who paid over $3,000 found "gullies already forming" just over a year in, causing back and joint issues.

What This Means for You

The pattern suggests Scott Living mattresses may be initially comfortable but variable in long-term durability. This could depend on:

• Body weight: Heavier sleepers put more stress on foam layers
• Model selection: Different models in the line have different foam densities
• Foundation: Proper support underneath affects longevity
• Manufacturing variance: Some individual mattresses may perform better than others

The Warranty Reality

A 10-year warranty sounds reassuring, but warranty claims can be tricky. Many warranties exclude "normal" body impressions under a certain depth (often 1.5 inches). You may feel the problem before it meets warranty criteria. Always read warranty terms carefully before purchasing.

Questions to Ask Before Buying

If you're considering Scott Living:

1. What's the foam density in the comfort layer? Higher density generally means better durability
2. What's the specific warranty coverage for body impressions?
3. Can you try the mattress in person before purchasing?
4. What's the return policy if it doesn't work for you?
5. Does the retailer have a track record with warranty service?

Alternatives Worth Considering

If you like the hybrid concept but want proven durability, consider mattresses from manufacturers with longer track records specifically in hybrid construction. Hybrid mattresses from established sleep companies often use higher-density foams that hold up better over time.

Our Recommendation

Scott Living mattresses aren't bad products. Many people genuinely love them. But the durability concerns mean you should:

• Try before buying whenever possible
• Understand the warranty terms completely
• Buy from a retailer who will stand behind the purchase
• Consider whether the price point matches the durability expectations

Try Mattresses in Person

At our Brantford store, we carry various hybrid mattresses you can actually lie on. Come to 441½ West Street, try different options, and ask us about the durability track records of different brands. We'll give you honest answers about what lasts and what doesn't.

Mattress Miracle: honest mattress advice since 1987.